From Zero to $500K. 5 Lessons I learned from 5,650+ Projects
This is 5+ years of writing & marketing knowledge compressed into a short read.
But my first sale as a writer on Fiverr… it wasn’t smooth sailing.
June 14, 2020: Three Facebook ad copies at $13 each. The client's feedback?
I scrapped everything and started over. Twice.
The order finally auto-completed 13 days later without so much as a "thank you" or a review. It took 13 days to earn $40.
Most people would have quit right there, but strangely enough, this proved to me that it WAS possible to make money writing online.
Four years later, I've generated over $535,000 on Fiverr alone, completed more than 5,650 projects, have over 3,000 five-star reviews, and been named among Fiverr's Recommended Sellers for 2025—placing me in the top 0.03% of approx. 400,000 active sellers.
Generating half a million dollars writing on Fiverr wasn’t pretty, or easy. But it was filled with clear patterns that ANYONE can replicate.
In this post, I'll share the five lessons I wish someone had shared with me.
Whether you're just starting out or already established, these principles apply across any platform and industry.
Let’s get into it.
Lesson 1: Niche Down (and Then Niche Down Again)
When I started on Fiverr, I learned quickly that "copywriter" was too broad. My success came from specialising in specific types of copy: Facebook ad copy, plain-text emails, landing pages, website copy.
I deliberately avoided branching into design or management services despite client requests. By focusing on these core writing services, I established myself as a specialist rather than a generalist.
This focused approach made it easier for clients to find me when searching for specific keywords and positioned me as an expert rather than a jack-of-all-trades.
Further down the line this also led me to being recognised by Fiverr in their Pro categories for the niche down services I provide.
Action steps:
Identify your strongest skills within your broader service category
Create separate gigs for each specialised service
Resist the temptation to expand beyond your core expertise
Lesson 2: Master the Art of the Upsell
My revenue increased when I started offering add-ons that complemented my core services.
For Facebook ad clients: Audience targeting suggestions and video scripts
For landing page clients: Extra headline variations or an FAQ section
For email clients: Complementary SMS and DM copy
…you get the idea.
These aren't random upsells. They're natural extensions that improve the effectiveness of the primary deliverable.
It makes sense to show your Facebook/Instagram ads to the right audience from day one. This is why targeting suggestions are the perfect upsell to ad copy.
Clients appreciate these suggestions because they solve problems they'd otherwise need to handle separately and find another expert to provide.
Action steps:
Identify what clients typically need next after using your service
Create standardised upsell packages addressing these needs
Introduce these options at multiple touchpoints before and after the client has purchased your core service
Lesson 3: Communication is King (and Queen)
Just like all platforms, Fiverr rewards fast response times. This is why I aim to reply to all messages within 60 minutes during business hours.
Even if it’s a simple “I’ll get back to you when I’m back to my laptop”, you are providing a response and keeping the prospect in the loop.
For after-hours coverage, I am experimenting with Fiverr's new feature for 2025.
I have my AI Personal Assistant "Echo" respond when I'm unavailable, i.e., between the hours of 12-4 AM. This ensures clients never feel ignored, regardless of their time zone, and I can pick up the conversation when I am back at my laptop.
Clear, prompt communication has been just as important to my success as the quality of my copywriting. Clients repeatedly mention my responsiveness in reviews.
Action steps:
Set up notification alerts for new messages
Create template ‘quick’ responses for standard questions
If possible, use assistant features for after-hours coverage
Lesson 4: Build Systems for Scalability
Writing content without systems is like trying to fill a bathtub with the drain open. You work harder but NEVER get ahead.
Working on 100+ projects each month has enabled me to develop three simple systems to help manage my workload:
1. Two-Touch Follow-Up System
24-hour follow-up: "Just checking if you had any questions about [specific aspect of their project]"
72-hour check-in: "I have availability opening up next week if you're still interested in [solving their specific problem]"
This simple sequence doubled my conversion rate for cold inquiries.
2. Project Dashboard System
I created a Google Sheet with columns for:
Client name
Package purchased
Order date and delivery date/time
Current status i.e. in progress or delivered
Niche/industry
This eliminated the mental load of remembering project details and made tracking various deadlines easier.
3. Client Communication System
Using Fiverr's tag feature, I categorise clients as:
Hot Lead (we’ve exchanged at least two messages and they are interested)
Warm Lead (they’ve not responded to my two follow-up messages. This is a reminder to follow up within the next couple of weeks)
Re Engage (follow-ups with old clients to highlight new services I am offering)
This prioritisation ensures I invest time where it matters most. The key here is having the right systems that address your specific bottlenecks.
Action steps:
Create a standardised follow-up schedule for inquiries
Implement a project tracking system (spreadsheet, Monday.com, Trello, etc.)
Use the platform features to categorise client communications
Lesson 5: Treat Every Gig Like a $500 Gig
Quality is non-negotiable regardless of project size.
My process includes:
Allowing 24 hours between first draft and final editing for a fresh perspective
Offering return buyer discounts and coupons to reward loyalty
Delivering all work in Google Docs format for transparent editing and collaboration
The Google Docs approach has been particularly effective, as it allows clients to see my thought process through comments and creates a seamless revision experience.
Action steps:
Build time for edits and new perspectives into your workflow
Create a loyalty programme for repeat clients
Choose delivery formats that facilitate collaboration
What Happens When My Clients Experience These 5 Lessons in Action…
You can check out more reviews here on my Fiverr profile.
Final Thoughts
My journey from a difficult first sale to $535,000 on Fiverr came down to five key principles:
Niche down into specific types of services
Create upsells that complement your core services
Personally respond to clients as fast as possible or use systems
Build systematic follow-up frameworks
Maintain consistent levels of quality
Most marketers and content writers get stuck at $0 or $2-3K/month because they treat a services-based business like a side gig rather than a business.
You don't need to implement all five lessons at once. Start with just one. Small shifts mean you are taking a step in the right direction.
Which lesson resonated most with you? Drop a comment below—I read and respond to every message.
Until next time,
Sam
What Did You Think of Issue #1 in the Sam’s Perspective Series?
👍 Loved it. Refer to a friend or drop a 🙌 below.
📖 You can read Fiverr’s Fiverr 2025 Annual Ebook here to find top talent.
🙌